Monday, June 16, 2008
Merchant Cash Advance Cost Comparison
I have received several emails about the cost of a merchant cash advance compared to other working capital solutions. One selling point of this product is that while it's more expensive compared to traditional small business loans (assuming the merchant can qualify for a small business loan as especially in this credit crunch, banks have raised their small business loan criteria even higher), the cost is pale in comparison to any equity solution including taking on additional investors and/or giving up equity in your business. Keep in mind that a merchant cash advance is not a loan product and does not have absolute repayment like a loan which also requires a MCA provider to charge more for that compared to a traditional small business loan. With a merchant cash advance, once you sell a MCA provider your future credit card / debit card receivables that is all the MCA provider is entitled to, no future upside in the business, no profit sharing etc. So what is more expensive? A) Selling your future credit card receivables / debit card receivables at an average discount of 26% or B) Giving someone a percentage of your business forever or until you have to buy them out a premium? I can assure you that option "B" will far exceed any discount that you sold your future credit card / debit card receivables for.
Wednesday, June 4, 2008
Merchant Cash Advance Provider Fast Capital Ceases Operations
It appears that merchant cash advance provider Fast Capital has ceased operations. It is rumored that another merchant cash advance provider will be managing their existing portfolio / customer base for their lender, Goldman Sachs. It will be interesting to see the outcome of this.
Tuesday, May 27, 2008
Cover Story On AdvanceMe Merchant Cash Advance Patent Appeal
The cover story of the May 23rd edition of ISO & Agent Weekly titled, "Court Says AdvanceMe Has No Cash-Advance Patent" was an interesting article from all perspectives of this landmark ruling for the merchant cash advance industry.
In addition, in this issue, they feature a story called "Association Formed For Cash Advances" which talks about the newly formed North American Merchant Advance Association which has been receiving praise throughout the industry.
In addition, in this issue, they feature a story called "Association Formed For Cash Advances" which talks about the newly formed North American Merchant Advance Association which has been receiving praise throughout the industry.
Thursday, May 15, 2008
AdvanceMe Loses Merchant Cash Advance Patent Appeal
I just received word that AdvanceMe has lost their appeal on their patent. I thought the call I got was a joke because the hearing was just last Tuesday, turns out the court realized in two seconds that there was no merit to this appeal. It shows you how little basis AdvanceMe had to even appeal this decision. You can see the court's document by clicking here.
The Electronic Transaction Association (ETA) has already reported on this "lightning fast" ruling as well. Click here for the story.
The Electronic Transaction Association (ETA) has already reported on this "lightning fast" ruling as well. Click here for the story.
Wednesday, May 14, 2008
Merchant Pleads Guilty To Merchant Cash Advance Fraud
A Virginia merchant committed fraud on several merchant cash advance providers and is facing up to 20 years in prison, $1 million in fines and had to surrender his house, car and motorcycles. The story can be found here.
This merchant fraudulently took a business cash advance from several MCA providers in his customer's names. One of the missions of the recently announced North American Merchant Advance Association is to prevent fraud like this from occurring.
This merchant fraudulently took a business cash advance from several MCA providers in his customer's names. One of the missions of the recently announced North American Merchant Advance Association is to prevent fraud like this from occurring.
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Merchant Cash Advance Association - Another Article In The Green Sheet
The North American Merchant Advance Association has been receiving positive press in all the trade publications since it was publicly announced on April 15th that the leading merchant cash advance providers have come together. The Green Sheet has just written a story about it titled, Cash advance leaders advance.
Tuesday, April 29, 2008
Merchant Cash Advance Closing Fees / Consulting Fees / Personal Service Fees (PSF)
I've received countless emails about what my opinion is on agents / ISOs charging a customer an additional upfront fee on a merchant cash advance such as closing fees, consulting fees, finder's fees and/or personal service fees (PSF) and the answer is to the merchants "stay away and run." You can easily find another merchant cash advance provider that won't charge you any upfront fees and will save you potentially thousands of dollars. These fees put unnecessary strain on both the merchant and increases the risk to the merchant cash advance provider.
This money is expensive enough without an agent / reseller tacking on additional costs to the merchant. Merchants should know that an agent / reseller / ISO is receiving up to 36% of the fees that a merchant cash advance is charging the customer. For example, if a merchant receives a $20,000 advance and the payback is $27,600, the agent bringing the deal to the MCA provider can be receiving up to $2,760 in commission. The merchant is selling their receivable to the MCA provider at a $7,600 discount and the salesperson is receiving $2,760 of the $7,600 (which is 36% of the fees being charged).
Now for a agent to charge another 5% - 10% of the funded amount to the customer ($1,000 - $2,000) turns the deal from a 1.38 factor in this example to the merchant receiving $18,000 and paying back $27,600 turns the arrangement into a 1.53 factor (up from a 1.38), a huge strain on the merchant and increases the chance of merchant default as well as increased risk for the merchant cash advance provider. The agent is then earning it on both sides from the customer and the merchant cash advance provider and in this example earning $4,760 of the $7,600 discount (62% of the fees charged the customer). There is an old saying, the bears make the money, the bulls make the money and the pigs get slaughtered.
I've been told by some agents that there is no way they can make money without charging closing fees, my response to that is I've owned merchant cash advance agencies and you can easily make a lot of money in this business, especially with the equity value you build with merchant processing residual. For those that can't figure out how to make money without charging closing fees, please feel free to contact me and I would be happy to discuss a very viable model. My rebuttal to that is for those agents that have sold credit card processing, when is the last time you made $4,000 upfront on a merchant account plus receive the monthly credit card residual? Selling credit card processing is far more competitive compared to merchant cash advance.
There has been some negative press as of late about some of the sales practices in our industry and almost every single instance involved a sales agent / reseller charging an upfront fee on a merchant cash advance.
As the industry comes together to establish best practices, I would imagine and hope charging upfront fees will be one item that merchant cash advance providers prohibit.
This money is expensive enough without an agent / reseller tacking on additional costs to the merchant. Merchants should know that an agent / reseller / ISO is receiving up to 36% of the fees that a merchant cash advance is charging the customer. For example, if a merchant receives a $20,000 advance and the payback is $27,600, the agent bringing the deal to the MCA provider can be receiving up to $2,760 in commission. The merchant is selling their receivable to the MCA provider at a $7,600 discount and the salesperson is receiving $2,760 of the $7,600 (which is 36% of the fees being charged).
Now for a agent to charge another 5% - 10% of the funded amount to the customer ($1,000 - $2,000) turns the deal from a 1.38 factor in this example to the merchant receiving $18,000 and paying back $27,600 turns the arrangement into a 1.53 factor (up from a 1.38), a huge strain on the merchant and increases the chance of merchant default as well as increased risk for the merchant cash advance provider. The agent is then earning it on both sides from the customer and the merchant cash advance provider and in this example earning $4,760 of the $7,600 discount (62% of the fees charged the customer). There is an old saying, the bears make the money, the bulls make the money and the pigs get slaughtered.
I've been told by some agents that there is no way they can make money without charging closing fees, my response to that is I've owned merchant cash advance agencies and you can easily make a lot of money in this business, especially with the equity value you build with merchant processing residual. For those that can't figure out how to make money without charging closing fees, please feel free to contact me and I would be happy to discuss a very viable model. My rebuttal to that is for those agents that have sold credit card processing, when is the last time you made $4,000 upfront on a merchant account plus receive the monthly credit card residual? Selling credit card processing is far more competitive compared to merchant cash advance.
There has been some negative press as of late about some of the sales practices in our industry and almost every single instance involved a sales agent / reseller charging an upfront fee on a merchant cash advance.
As the industry comes together to establish best practices, I would imagine and hope charging upfront fees will be one item that merchant cash advance providers prohibit.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)